Hedging is risk reduction, not profit-seeking. It differs from speculation, which bets on a market direction, and from diversification, which spreads risk across many holdings from the start.
A hedge narrows outcomes. It cuts the worst-case loss but also trims returns in good scenarios, by exactly the cost of the premium in the example.
Protection is temporary. Options expire, so keeping a hedge in place means paying a new premium each time, and time decay erodes the hedge's value when it isn't needed.
No method is guaranteed. Every approach carries its own costs and risks, so weigh them against the risk of doing nothing.
What Is Hedging?
Hedging means reducing risk. Hedging in investment means buying a secondary asset that you think will move up, whenever your primary asset moves down. A hedge may reduce risk, but does not remove it completely. A hedge mechanism will usually cost you something, so think of it as a form of insurance.
How a hedge works (the offsetting principle)
When you hedge, you are trying to pick an instrument that tends to gain when the main position loses. A full hedge covers the whole value of your position, while a partial hedge covers only part of it (for example 50%). This percentage is called "Hedge ratio".
Hedge ratio
If you want to simulate a hedging scenario, you can try our hedge ratio calculator:
Hedging targets a specific stock or instrument that you hold, while diversification is spreading your money across many investments from the start. Hedging and diversification are different methods of managing risk in investment.
Hedging vs speculation
Hedging means you are not looking to make profit, but trying to reduce the effect of volatility on an investment. Speculating means making a trade based on your belief that the market is going in a certain direction, hoping to make profit.
Common ways investors hedge stock positions
Offsetting positions
Protective put: A put option gives its buyer the right, but not the obligation, to sell 100 shares at a fixed price (the strike) any time before the option expires. This involves premium, which is a cost you pay upfront for that right. You don't get it back, whatever happens.
Short selling: The simplest explanation is: you borrow a stock, usually one which correlates with your main investment, and sell it for money. If the stock price falls, you return the borrowed stock using less money than when you borrowed them. Important note: because a stock's price can keep rising, a loss on a short sale has no fixed limit, and you will pay to borrow the shares.
Inverse or short ETFs: these are funds built to rise when a market index falls. Most of them reset daily, so over longer periods, their returns can move away from the index.
Pairs trades. You invest in one stock and short a close competitor, to hopefully reduce the risk from one specific company.
Other non-derivative approaches
Diversification: Spreading money across sectors, asset classes, and geographies, to reduce risks specifically tied to those categories.
Asset allocation: Holding assets other than stocks such as bonds, cash, or treasuries might reduce your portfolio volatility.
Stop-loss orders: This is an order to automatically sell if the price drops to a level you set. This is not a guaranteed exit. If the price gaps further down, the "sell" action can fill well below your level.
Position sizing: Selling part of a position (or limiting the size from the start) reduces risk directly.
Example: hedging a stock position
Now let's take a look at a hypothetical example. The numbers below are illustrative only, so it's easy to follow. They are not a forecast for any real stock and not a recommendation to trade.
Let's say, you own 100 shares of a stock bought at $200 per share, so your position is worth $20,000. A standard US-listed equity option contract usually covers 100 shares of the underlying stock. In this case, this means one contract protects the whole position.
Step 2: Choose the protection
Now, let's say you buy a protective put with a strike price of $180, and it expires in three months. The strike is the price where it lets you sell your shares, at any time before expiry. This means you accept the first $20 per share of any drop (from $200) and the put covers losses beyond that.
Step 3: Pay the premium
In this example the put costs an illustrative premium of $6 per share, or $600 for the contract (100 x $6). This premium is paid upfront and is not refunded if the stock never falls. In real life, premiums will vary with stock volatility, the strike number, and expiry time.
Step 4: The outcome
This table shows your profit or loss three months later in three scenarios, including the $600 premium. Note: there may be commissions and taxes when trading in real life.
Scenario at expiry
Stock price
Without hedging
With hedging (premium included)
Price falls by 30%
$140
-$6,000 (-30%)
-$2,600 (-13%)
Price stays
$200
$0 (0%)
-$600 (-3%)
Price rises by 20%
$240
+$4,000 (+20%)
+$3,400 (+17%)
These are the example scenarios:
If price falls by 30%: your shares are worth $14,000, but the put lets you sell at $180, so you sold it for $18,000 in total. Minus the $600 premium, it becomes a net loss of $2,600 instead of $6,000.
Price stays flat: Since the price stays above $180, your protection expires and nothing happened. Your loss is the $600 premium.
Price rises 20%: Your protection expires. You keep the $4,000 gain on the shares, minus the $600 premium, for a net gain of $3,400.
A hedge may narrow the range of outcomes, but not eliminating risks. Protection lasts only until the put expires, so keeping it in place means paying a new premium each time.
What hedging really costs you
Premiums and time decay: A protective put loses value every day it isn't needed, and the decay accelerates as expiration nears.
Rolling: Protection expires, so a long-term hedge means repeatedly buying new options.
Transaction costs: These include commissions and bid-ask spreads. Spreads are wide on less liquid options, and rolling or adjusting multiplies them.
Other costs you should also consider (but might miss):
Tax effects: Some hedges can trigger constructive sale rules or reset holding periods, and option gains and losses may be taxed differently from the stock's.
Basis risk: Index hedges can fail to track your stock. If your stock falls while the index doesn't, you pay for a hedge that doesn't help.
Complexity: Managing multiple positions takes attention and skill, so keep your decision making ability in mind.
Hedging in trading vs hedging as a long-term investor
Hedging in trading is different than hedging in shares as long-term investors. A short term trader may want to hedge a specific stock during particular events or volatile times in the market. A long term investor may prefer to reduce risk by diversification or limiting position size. No method is guaranteed; every method carries its costs and risks.
Should you hedge?
There are a few questions which might help you consider hedging as an option:
How concentrated is the position? You may want to think about how big your main investment is, related to the total amount you have.
Could you tolerate the loss without hedging? Calculate the cost, risk, and mental pressure you take by hedging, then compare them to the risk of not hedging.
Is it simpler to rebalance or reduce the position? It might be more effective to limit the size from the start, and do something else with the rest of the money.
Conclusion
Hedging reduces risk rather than removing it. Hedging will always cost something: premiums, fees, missed upside opportunity, or added complexity. Use a hedge like you would use an insurance: it is worth buying only when you know what loss you're protecting against, and if the price is right. Before hedging, ask how concentrated the position is, whether you could tolerate the loss without a hedge, and whether reducing the position would be simpler.
Gotrade is the trading name of Gotrade Securities Inc., which is registered with and supervised by the Labuan Financial Services Authority (LFSA). This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Always do your own research (DYOR) before investing.
Sindhu Partomo is a copywriter and content writer with 8+ years of experience in agencies, B2B, and SaaS. He has been writing about business and finance since 2023, and holds a bachelor degree from University of Indonesia.
Hendrie Saputra holds a Master of Business Administration (MBA) with a concentration in Business Risk & Finance, along with professional experience in finance, marketing, and project management. He is experienced in analyzing market data and developing research-driven business strategies.